Estate Planning Forms, Wills & Trusts

Pennyborn.com™

Estate Planning

Financial Decisions

Title to Property

Social Security Benefits

Domestic Partners

For Women

State Laws

Newsworthy Cases

Estate Plan Tips & FAQs

Glossary of Terms A-G

Glossary of Terms H-N

Glossary of Terms O-Z

Unequal Shares

Dying Without a Will

Wills & Trusts

Types of Wills

Living Trusts

Other Types of Trusts

Trust Law

Fatal Errors in Execution

Codicils/Amendments

Inheritances

Will & Trust Disputes

Disinheriting an Heir

Community Property

Change My Will

Specific Bequests

Making Specific Bequests

Medical Decisions

Living Wills

Health Care POA

Medical Decision Laws

Terminal Illness

Right to Die

DNR Orders

Advance Directives

Children

Guardianship

Single Parents

Blended Families

Special Needs Trusts

College Funds

Medicaid for Children

Gifts to Minors UTMA

Adopted Children

NonMarital Children

Dependent Adult Child

Child Guardian Letter

Lump Sum Inheritance

Estate Taxes

Gifts and Gifting

Charitable Giving

The Marital Deduction

Find a Tax Professional

Generation Skipping Tax

Inheritance Tax

Estate Tax Info

Pets

Pet Trusts

Pet Retirement Homes

The Law on Pet Trusts

Funding Pet Trusts

Letter to Pet Guardian

Pet Owners Estate Plan

Pet Trust Info

Memorial Preferences

Funerals & Services

Cremation

Burial Options

Funeral/Burial Expenses

Organ Donation

Disposition of Remains

Funeral PrePaying

Write an Epitaph

List of Epitaphs

Burial Assistance

Write Last Wishes Letter

Life Insurance

Types of Policies

Viatical Settlements

Insurance Companies

Life Insurance Trusts

On Adult Children

Financial Planning

IRA's & Your Estate Plan

401K's & Your Estate Plan

Annuities & Your Estate

Find a Financial Planner

Long-Term Care Insurance

LTC Policy Fine Print

Inherited IRA's

Charitable Gift Annuities

Small Business

Types of Entities

Shareholders Agreements

Business Succession Plans

Selling the Business

Need for Liquidity

Probate

Probate of Small Estates

Probate an Estate

Probate Questions

Probate Lawyer

Executor Bonds

Free Probate Guide

Estate Administration

For Executors

Executor Checklist

Executor Powers

Creditor Claims

Estate Property Form

Tax Returns Due

Safe Deposit Boxes

File Will of Deceased

Death Certificate

Issues facing Seniors

Tips for Seniors

Info for BabyBoomers

Long Term Care

Assisted Living

Medicaid Planning

Dementia & Wills

Funerals and Medicaid

Books & Software

Estate Planning Books

Software

Will & Trust Books

Books About Probate

Funeral Planning Books

Medicaid Planning Books

Books for Trustees

Living Will Books

IRA 401k & Annuity Books

Estate Tax Books

Long Term Care Books

Last Wishes Planners

Free Estate Planning

Free Estate Plan Forms

Last Wishes

Estate Plan Coversheet

Estate Planning Worksheet

Pet Guardian Form

Contesting a Will

Holographic Wills

Undue Influence

Proving Undue Influence

More About Trusts

QTIP Trusts

CharitableRemainderTrusts

PowerofAppointment Trusts

Spendthrift Trusts

Dynasty Trusts

Minor's Trust

Crummey Trusts

Irrevocable Trusts

Terminate a Trust

Guide to Living Trusts

Benefits of Living Trusts

Living Trust Checklist

Living Trust Property

Revoke Living Trust

Forms for Trustees

For Successor Trustees

Trust Administration

For Trustees

Trustee Checklist

Living Trust Accounting

Trust Accounting

Open Trust Account

Administer a Trust

How to End a Trust

Trust Law Sources

Spouses & Partners

Spousal Share

Partner's Share

Joint Wills

Required to File Will

Disinherit-a-Spouse

Title-Property-Disinherit

Legacy Planning

Unwanted Pets

Animal Charities

Non-Probate Transfers

Pay on Death Accounts

Transfer on Death

Funeral Planning Guide

Best Funeral Songs

Last Wishes Letter

How to Plan Your Funeral

Greedy Heirs

Adult Child's Inheritance

Protecting Parents From

Greedy Siblings

Estate Planning Questions

Safe Deposit Box

Leave Stock in Your Will

Questions-About-POAs

Why Leave Last Wishes

Heirs and Beneficiaries

Debts Owed to Deceased

 
The Case of Marshall v. Stern
On March 19, 2010, the United States Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit ruled against the Estate of Anna Nicole Smith on her claim against the Estate of J. Howard Marshall. The wealthy oil tycoon had a will and a living trust that left almost all of his estate to his youngest son, E. Pierce Marshall. His will and living trust left nothing to Anna Nicole Smith, even though she was married to Marshall at the time of his death. At the time, she was known as Vickie Lynn Marshall.

To reduce the cost of probate or avoid probate, J. Howard Marshall had placed the bulk of his assets in a revocable living trust. At the time of his death, the primary beneficiary of the living trust was E. Pierce Marshall. Marshall also made a will which contained pour-over provisions directing that his probate estate be distributed to his living trust. After marrying Smith, Marshall executed documents making his living trust irrevocable. He did not name Smith a beneficiary of his will or living trust, nor did he make any other provisions for her in his estate plan. He did, however, bestow lavish gifts on Smith, including real estate, cash, and personal property reportedly worth somewhere in the range of $7 million.

The 9th Circuit Court ruled in Marshall v. Stern that Anna Nicole Smith’s estate is not entitled to receive any distribution from J. Howard Marshall’s estate, which is estimated to be worth $1.6 billion. This is a much different result than previous court decisions in this estate dispute which had awarded Smith millions of dollars.



Marshall’s heirs have been battling over his fortune for nearly 15 years. Both of the original parties to the case are now deceased. The fight over his estate is now being carried on by Howard K. Stern, executor of Smith’s estate, and Elaine T. Marshall, executrix of E. Pierce Marshall’s estate.

The legal arguments surrounding Marshall’s estate plan have already been heard by the United States Supreme Court. This most recent decision by the 9th Circuit was rendered after the nation’s highest court remanded the case to the 9th Circuit after determining the lower court had construed the probate exception to its subject matter jurisdiction too broadly. The dispute over Marshall’s estate has been heard in several different types of courts, including bankruptcy court and probate court. There are many different claims in the case and the legal battle between the heirs is too lengthy to summarize here. The entire opinion issued by the 9th Circuit on March 19, 2010 is available on the United States Courts for the Ninth Circuit website.


Prevent Will and Trust Disputes
What steps could someone in J. Howard Marshall’s position have taken in his estate plan to prevent his wife from inheriting more than her elective share and avoid a costly will and trust dispute among his heirs? If you have an heir intent on filing a claim against your estate, it can be difficult to prevent, even with the best estate plan. Furthermore, if your estate is worth anything close to $1.6 billion, there is so much an heir can possibly gain that a will contest is likely, even after the proper steps are taken to disinherit an heir. Nevertheless, if you own a significant amount of property, have children from a prior marriage, and enter a new marriage or relationship, there are several steps you can take to ensure your estate is distributed to your intended beneficiaries. These steps include:

1. Use an experienced estate planning attorney to prepare your estate plan. Make sure your attorney is fully aware of your concerns about a will contest so he or she can include appropriate language to achieve your objectives. See finding an attorney.

2. If you intend to disinherit a spouse, child, or another heir, you should specifically mention that person by name in your will and state your reasons for the disinheritance.

3. Consult an estate planning attorney regarding the elective share such disinherited heir may be entitled to inherit under the laws of your state, and plan your estate accordingly. See spousal share.

4. Include a no-contest clause in your will, and ensure the heir you are trying to disinherit has a significant amount to lose by challenging your will.

5. Consult your attorney about having your will signing videotaped. If your attorney recommends it, arrange for a professional to videotape your will signing.

6. If there is any possibility an heir could claim you were subject to undue influence or lacked competency to make a will, ask your attorney to include competency questions in your estate planning documents to demonstrate your competency at the time of executing your estate plan.


Update on the Marshall v. Stern Case
On September 28, 2010, the United States Supreme Court announced it will hear an appeal by the estate of Anna Nicole Smith in the Marshall v. Stern case. This is the second time the nation’s highest court has agreed to hear an appeal in this long-running estate litigation.

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against Smith’s estate in March of 2010. Now, Smith’s heirs will have another opportunity to pursue their claim against the estate of the late J. Howard Marshall. The Supreme Court is expected to hear the case in late 2010 or early 2011.


More Trust and Estate Cases
To read about other cases involving estate planning, wills, trusts, and probate, see our Estate Planning Blog and our Celebrity Estates page.


Estate Planning and Trust Administration Guide

Copyright © 2009 - 2019 Pennyborn.com. All articles, forms, and images on Pennyborn.com are copyrighted. PENNYBORN is a federal trademark. All Rights Reserved. Your use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

INFORMATION ON THIS SITE, INCLUDING ARTICLES, ESTATE PLANNING FORMS, AND THE ESTATE PLANNING BLOG, IS NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Pennyborn.com is not a law firm and is not a substitute for a lawyer. Your use of this site does not create an attorney-client relationship.

THIS WEBSITE USES COOKIES. BY USING THIS SITE YOU ARE PROVIDING US WITH YOUR CONSENT TO THE PLACEMENT OF THESE COOKIES. PLEASE READ OUR PRIVACY POLICY WHICH CONTAINS MORE INFORMATION ON HOW WE USE COOKIES.